Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton investigates Texas hospital's refusal to transplant organs to unvaccinated people

Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton is investigating a Texas hospital’s refusal to perform organ transplants for unvaccinated people

Houston Methodist Hospital is under scrutiny after reports emerged that it may have refused or delayed organ transplants for patients who declined the COVID-19 vaccine. Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton launched a preliminary investigation into the allegations, warning that such policies could violate state law and ethical medical standards.

Texas AG investigates vaccine policy: Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton sent a letter to Houston Methodist Hospital demanding clarification on whether its transplant policies comply with these obligations. House Bill 4076which prohibits discrimination against organ transplant patients based on vaccination status.

Claims of the need for a Covid-19 vaccine: The investigation follows the reports and Document 2024 Suggesting that Houston Methodist has required kidney transplant recipients to receive the COVID-19 vaccine, it is allegedly postponing procedures until proof of vaccination is provided.

The hospital denies the allegations: Houston Methodist to reject Has no policy requiring COVID-19 or other vaccines for transplant eligibility, noting that it “does not deny care based on vaccination status” and is in full compliance with state law.

Deadline to respond: Paxton gave the hospital 14 days (until October 27) To respond with written confirmation of compliance, warning that failure to do so may result in… Official state investigation In possible violations of Texas law.

A hospital in Texas may face an investigation after allegations it may refuse organ transplants to patients who refuse an experimental COVID-19 vaccine

On October 2, the Health Care Enforcement Division of the Texas Office of the Attorney General (OAG) sent a formal letter to Houston Methodist President and CEO Mark L. Boom, the hospital gives two weeks to clarify its transplant policies. The investigation stems from accusations that the hospital required kidney transplant candidates to receive the COVID-19 vaccine as a prerequisite for surgery — an action that may conflict with new state laws that protect patients from discrimination based on vaccination status.

Paxton’s office cited House Bill 4076was passed during the 89th legislative session and signed into law by Gov. Greg Abbott in June 2024. The legislation, authored by Rep. Jeff Leach (R-Plano), explicitly prohibits health care facilities and physicians from denying, delaying, or deprioritizing organ transplants to patients based solely on their vaccination choices. The law took effect on September 1, 2024.

“Texans looking to receive medical care should never be turned away due to arbitrary COVID-19 vaccine mandates imposed by medical providers,” Paxton’s letter stressed. He further asserted that mandating the vaccine as a prerequisite for life-saving procedures not only violates state law, but also violates human dignity and is inconsistent with basic principles of medical ethics.

The controversy has been reignited before Dr. Mary Talley Bowdena doctor who was previously fired by Houston Methodist after prescribing the drug ivermectin to COVID-19 patients. In July 2024, Bowden posted on X (formerly Twitter) a screenshot purporting to be from the hospital’s kidney transplant program evaluation and waiting list clinical practice guidelines (CPG). “The kidney transplant will be postponed until the recipient receives the Covid-19 vaccine,” the document stated. Patients are also required to provide documentation if they have been vaccinated elsewhere.

Bowden claimed that to her knowledge, Houston Methodist’s transplant policy “has not changed” and that she had evidence on tape of hospital staff confirming the vaccination requirements. She shared the alleged document publicly, arguing that it clearly shows discrimination against unvaccinated patients.

In her response, Houston Methodist Hospital has strongly denied the allegations. In a statement to KHOU 11, the hospital said: “Houston Methodist does not have a policy requiring transplant patients to be vaccinated against COVID-19, or any other disease, and does not deny care based on vaccination status. We comply with all state laws, and as one of the largest transplant programs in the country, the safety of our patients always comes first.” The hospital also acknowledged receipt of the Attorney General’s letter and indicated that it would provide a full response soon.

Despite the hospital’s denials, the district attorney’s office gave Houston Methodist even more notice October 27 To provide documentation confirming compliance with HB 4076 and details any changes to its transplant eligibility protocols. Paxton warned that failure to comply could lead to a formal investigation by the state.

This latest dispute adds to ongoing tensions at the hospital over COVID-19 vaccine policies. In 2021, it became Houston Methodist First hospital system in the United States to mandate vaccination as a condition of employmentThis sparked nationwide controversy and multiple lawsuits from employees who objected for religious or medical reasons. While the hospital has maintained exemptions for some employees, the policy has drawn criticism from vaccine-skeptic groups and conservative lawmakers.

The current accusations highlight the broader clash between the two countries Public health policy and individual medical autonomy Which has continued since the outbreak of the epidemic. Texas, in particular, has enacted several laws restricting vaccine mandates in the workplace, education, and health care settings. HB 4076 extends these protections to organ transplant recipients, reflecting growing legislative efforts to ensure that access to medical care is not conditional on vaccination status.

As the October 27 deadline approaches, both sides remain firm on their positions. The attorney general insists that Texas will adhere to its anti-discrimination laws “to protect patients’ rights and preserve medical ethics,” while Houston Methodist maintains that it fully adheres to state regulations and prioritizes patient safety. The outcome of this case could set an important precedent for how hospitals across Texas — and perhaps the nation — balance medical protocol with individual liberty in the post-pandemic era.

Bookmark Vaccine news To your favorite independent websites for updates on experimental gene therapy injections leading to premature death, infertility, teratogenic cancer and Longfax syndrome.

Sources for this article include:

(Tags for translation). Vaccines