The Republican Party falsely links the government to the alleged attempt by Democrats to provide medical attention to all immigrants

While the United States was heading towards the closure of the government, the Republicans have repeatedly accused the Democrats of forcing this closure because they wanted migrants in the country without obtaining medical care.

“The Democrats threaten the closure of the entire government because they want to give hundreds of billions of dollars in the advantages of medical care for illegal immigrants,” said Vice President GD Vans. September 28 en “Fox News Sunday”.

President Donald TrumpParliament Speaker, Mike Johnson, and Republican members of Congress repeatedly repeated this.

It is a wrong statement.

Democrats refused to vote in favor of the Republican Decree to extend the deadline for federal expenditures, and their location, in part, depends on the spending of medical care.

Democrats want to extend the subsidy health care law subsidies (ACA) in the Covid era, whose validity ends at the end of the year, and the reversal of the discounts to Medicaid listed in the Tax and Expenditure Laws of Trump this summer.

the Democratic proposal He will not provide medical attention to migrants without legal status; This population is, largely, not qualified for the medical government funded by the federal government. On the other hand, the proposal will be brought to some medical care programs for immigrants with papers that are lost under Republican law.

The White House did not respond to the politifact comments for this data verification. Vans Responded to criticism In his argument in another interview, saying that he was included in proposing democratic spending. This is not.

A White House account in x He continued to publish screenshots for a democratic proposal that cancels a part of the Republican Law called “Aliens for Medicaid”. It is important to know that these changes will not allow Medicaid to be accessed for immigrants without legal status.

Vans defended his statement again in a press conference In the White House on October 1, he said that former President Joe Biden “canceled the state of illegal immigration,” which facilitated the access to federal assistance.

It is important to keep in mind that many people are It gives the legal status Through humanitarian permits or temporary protection programs (TPS), you do not automatically qualify to get Medicaid; TPS beneficiaries are not qualifiedAnd many people who entered the country with a human ear should wait five years before reaching the program.

The Trump administration has canceled the humanitarian permit and TPS for many people, making it unhappy to get Medicaid and the health plans for the ACA market.

We do not find evidence that Democrats want to spend hundreds of billions on costs so that immigrants who do not have healthy insurance papers.

Immigrants are no longer without legal status

Most Federal Medical Care cannot be spent on people in the country without papers. They cannot register in Medicaid or Medicare, and they are not qualified to obtain medical coverage through the insurance markets created by ACA.

The small Medicaid program pays hospital for emergency medical care for people who do not have medical insurance, which may include migrants in the country without permission, but not exclusive to them.

States like Illinois and California They used to cover medical aid For people, regardless of their migration, countries pay the price of this coverage. Federal law has already banned countries to use federal funds for these programs. A Previous version Among the law of republican expenditures, he would have punished these states that retain money, but this ruling did not last.

People in the country cannot obtain medical care with funding from the federal government in emergency situations; In these cases, hospitals must provide care even if the person does not have a medical insurance or does not have papers. Medical emergency covers hospital care for migrants who will be qualified to obtain medical aid from their absence of their immigration. The Law and Republican Expenditure Law Reduced Hospitals can receive this attention.

Most emergency medical expenses are for births. In total, like Less than 1 % of spending Total medicaid in the fiscal year 2023, according to KFF, a non -profit health information organization that includes KFF Health News.

Republican law is limited to medical care for immigrants with legal status

Republican Law on Taxes and Expenditures has made many changes in the eligibility of medical care for migrants who live in the country with the papers. It is able to do so 1.4 million legal immigrants They will lose their medical insurance, according to the KFF analysis on expectations Congress Budget Office.

As of October 2026, the law will restrict eligibility for the Medicaid program and the Child Medical Insurance Program (Chip) to the permanent legal population, to the people of the Marshall Islands, Micronesia, or Palaua, which legally resides in the country by virtue of International AgreementReally true Cubans and Haitians.

Previously, a large group, was defined as it “No qualified citizens”It meets the requirements of Medicaid and Chip, including refugees and people who have received asylum.

Some of the qualified immigrants for aid and chips, such as permanent legal residents, They must wait five years Before reaching the benefits.

The civil law has also been limited to obtaining insurance in the ACA markets for the same group eligible to obtain Medicaid and Chip as of January 1, 2027. “Gifts from a legal point of view” They were qualified. This group included “unqualified citizens” qualified to get Medicaid and people who have a short -term position, such as TPS or international students.

The beneficiaries of the improved work program for expatriates in childhood (DACA) have benefited for immigrants who have reached the country of children, without permission, in the past, the requirements for covering and supporting ACA. But they have not been eligible since then Trump management standard I entered into force in August.

The democratic proposal re -reaching legal immigrants

the Budget suggestion Among the Democrats, who were presented on September 17, it will partially extend the ACA submarines permanently, and will reflect billions of dollars from Republican discounts to medicaid and other health programs.

Change would make Medicaid and Chip coverage available here for all legal immigrants who have been qualified before, all of the refugees and people who received asylum.

The civil democratic proposal will not expand the medical care programs funded by the federal government of migrants without legal status.

Vans said that democratic policies will give hundreds of billions of dollars in the benefits of medical care for non -documented migrants, and the White House did not reveal the source of this number. when Johnson was pressed To support a similar argument, the CBO budget office required.

KFF analysis is about CBO estimates It was found that the provisions of Republican Law on legal immigrants will reduce federal spending by $ 131 billion; This projection did not include an estimate of people who have no legal status.

Our decision

“Democrats threaten the closure of the entire government because they want to give hundreds of billions of dollars in the benefits of medical care for illegal immigrants.”

Immigrants in the United States without a large legal permission are not qualified to obtain medical care programs funded by the federal government and medical and medical care, and they cannot request coverage in the ACA market or request subsidies.

The proposal of the Democrats budget will not change this.

Democrats want to restore access to some medical care programs for legal immigrants who will lose access under Republican Law on Taxes and Expenditures, among other measures aimed at facilitating the maintenance of Medicaid and ACA insurance plans.

Their proposal will not give the medical care subsidies by the federal government to the people in the country without legal permission, because they were unable to reach it first.

The small amount of the MEDICAID Emergency money pays hospitals that provide emergency care for migrants who will be qualified to obtain Medicaid if not due to the state of migration. Finally, we do not find evidence to support Vans’s statement that the Democrats want “hundreds of billions” in the health advantages of migrants illegally residing in the country.

We described this statement as a liar.

Our sources

Fox News,JD Vance Slams’ allegations “in the Umidi indictment:” Lying under the section “September 28, 2025.

White House, “”President Trump provides an advertisement“September 30, 2025.

President Donald Trump, Social truthSeptember 29, 2025.

US House of Representatives invoiceIt was reached on October 1, 2025.

Congress Budget Office, “Distribution effects of General Law 119-21“August 11, 2025.

Politifact, “Newsom Medicaid migrants illegally defended California. Now he wants to cut it“May 16, 2025.

KFF, “Health provisions in the Federal Budget Law 2025“July 8, 2025.

KFF, “Possible effects of the 2025 budget reconciliation on the health coverage of migratory families“June 17, 2025.

KFF, “The main facts about the health coverage of migrants“January 15, 2025.

KFF, “1.4 million is expected to legally lose current immigrants to health coverage due to the tax and budget law 2025“September 25, 2025.

American citizenship services and immigration “,”Information to save users: Cuban expatriates“It was reached on October 1, 2025.

American citizenship services and immigration “,”Place the citizens of the states that are freely associatedT, “reached on October 1, 2025.

Healthcare.gov, “Coverage for immigrants present legally“It was reached on October 1, 2025.

Federal registry, “Patient Protection and Care Law at reasonable prices; Market safety and the ability to bear costs“June 25, 2025.